As one of my colleagues has pointed out in their post, candy and sugary treats are now a huge “no no” in schools nationwide. While I am aware of the obesity problem, I can’t contribute that to candy in schools at all. To me it’s just ridiculous to do so. Obesity due to diet comes from home environment. If mom and dad eat unhealthy food, or if they allow junior to eat whatever he wants, not monitoring his junk food intake, then junior may become obese. Sugar in school doesn’t play much of a role, except in the cafeteria offerings. In that respect (the cafeteria) I believe schools should monitor the choices they offer, because we all know that when children are at school, it’s teachers jobs to act in loco parentis, in place of the parent.
But what about sugary treats in school? I think there is an ulterior motive. From my humble experiences teaching for 1 hour a week at my church to 15 third graders for ccd…. candy is evil!!!!! Go with me on this: Let’s take 15 already-hyper 8 yr olds. Now let’s have a party!!! Energy in the classroom is soaring. Okay, let’s add our final ingredient: sugary snacks. TAKE COVER!!!!! Man your bunkers people!!! A tiny bit is okay, b ut parties filled with candy and cookies and cupcakes just spells disaster. To that extent, whenever I have a “shindig” in my ccd class (we can’t actually have a “party” so I call it a “shindig”…politics…I know…) I ask parents NOT to bring anything in. There are two reasons for this: one, allergies. (Enough said). The other reason is that by bringing in a small snack myself, I monitor the sugar intake of my students and keep the classroom “shindig” at a manageable energy level. Trust me, things go a lot smoother if I don’t give my kids candy.
There is something else to consider about the candy and snack debate: A few of my CCD parents are very strict about their child’s intake of sweets. Parents have told me before they do not wish their child to be given sweets. In third grade, if there’s a party and everyone gets a cupcake but you, life’s totally not fair. I don’t want to do this to the students, so I clear any snacks with concerned parents beforehand. In the same respect, by avoiding handing out lots of sweets, I don’t make enemies of the parents. How would you like it if I sent your 8 year old home on a sugar high?
So I don’t really think obesity is the big problem here in the sugar debate. I feel there are many good reasons to keep sugar levels in school low. That does not mean I believe sugary snacks should be disallowed alltogethor. I simply feel that we need to really monitor our students’ intake of sugars during the school day. Everything in moderation!